14 Oct Shorts, Saturday Mornings, and Starbucks: Surviving the College Interview Stress
If you want to see a high school senior (and their parents) reach peak anxiety, just mention the word “Interview.”
The image alone is enough to induce a cold sweat: a seventeen-year-old sitting across from a 78-year-old alum at a crowded Starbucks or in a mahogany-filled law firm on a Saturday morning. It feels like a high-stakes interrogation, a performance where one wrong word—or one wrong outfit—could end the dream.
As a college counselor, I spend my days prepping students for these moments. But as a mother of three, I’ve learned that sometimes the best thing you can do is just… let go.
The October Shorts Incident
I vividly remember pulling into the parking lot for my daughter’s very first college interview. It was a crisp October day, the kind where the leaves are turning and there’s a definitive chill in the air.
Being a professional in this field, I turned to her and asked, “So, what are you wearing today?”
She looked at me with total confidence and said, “Shorts.”
I sat there for a moment. No words. As a counselor, my brain was screaming about first impressions and “business casual.” As a mom, I realized this was the moment where I had to sit on my hands yet again. I took a deep breath, stayed silent, and watched her walk into that building in her shorts.
And you know what? She was fine. More than fine. Because she felt like herself.
The “Human” Vibe Check
Here is the secret I tell my students at Academic Access: The college interview isn’t a test of your knowledge. It’s a vibe check.
Whether you are meeting a young admissions officer or a seasoned alum who graduated before your parents were born, they aren’t looking for a scripted robot. They are looking for a human being. They want to see if you are someone they’d want to sit next to in a freshman seminar or grab a coffee with in the student center.
When my daughter walked in wearing shorts, she was “coming as she was.” Was it traditional? No. Was she respectful? Absolutely. She was engaged, she was clever, and she was authentically her.
Joan’s Advice for the “Big Chat”
When it’s time for your student to head to that Starbucks or law office, here is how I suggest you frame it:
- Respectful, but Real: You don’t need a three-piece suit, but you do need to show you value the interviewer’s time. Aim for “polished version of yourself.” If you’re a creative, show that. If you’re a techie, show that. (And if it’s October, maybe check the weather—but I digress!)
- The “Why Us” Deep Dive: The interviewer knows your grades. What they want to know is why you actually want to spend four years on their campus. Have two or three specific things—a lab, a club, a specific professor—ready to talk about.
- Embrace the Generational Gap: If you’re meeting an older alum, ask them about what the campus was like when they were there. People love to share their stories, and it turns an interrogation into a conversation.
- The “Let Go” Moment for Parents: Parents, your job ends at the parking lot. Don’t go in. Don’t hover by the window. Give them the space to walk in alone, sit in that oversized leather chair or at that tiny bistro table, and advocate for themselves.
The Bottom Line
At the end of the day, an interview is just two people talking about a school they both (hopefully) care about. It’s a chance for the college to see the person behind the GPA.
My daughter’s shorts didn’t stop her from finding her “perfect spot,” and a Saturday morning at Starbucks won’t break your child’s application either. Encourage them to be respectful, be prepared, and above all, be themselves.
Even if “themselves” involves shorts in October.